Hobbit movie continuity errors

So theres a list of five of the continuity errors i caught while watching the office. Tolkien, with large portions of the trilogy inspired by the appendices to the return of the king, which expand on the story told in the hobbit, as well as new material and characters written especially for the films. All 6 peter jacksons middleearth movies ranked from worst to best. With such a prestigious history you may think the fellowship of the ring is above mistakes.

An example being thorin riding a goat in the theatrical cut seems out of nowhere, but in the extended version there is a calvary charge of them from the dwarves earlier, so you. In a way, it reminds me of how so many people got confused at the end of the 1st harry potter, wondering how the sorcerors stone got in his pocket. The extended edition of the hobbit battle of the five armies finally ends the saga, and this film is a high note to end on. The lord of the rings movie mistakes movie mistakes, spoilers, bloopers, goof and fails. Can lead to a continuity snarl or continuity drift a common feature of longrunners. In the previous scene, where he confronts bard and tries to have the barrels of fish dumped in the water, he hasnt got the yellow goo on his shoulder yet. The hobbit is a film series consisting of three high fantasy adventure films directed by peter jackson. The birth year for thorin given on the tapestry that bard finds in laketown is correct for the books continuity.

In most cases, these mistakes go unnoticed by the public. Tolkiens influential fantasy saga was one the most ambitious film projects ever made. The cases where it doesnt in the hobbit the entire character of tauriel winds up being completely pointless are less a issue. Jan 06, 20 some of the highestgrossing films in 2012 had errors in continuity.

Inside the tent, theres tons of other fireworks and equipment besides the firework that merry and. It was nominated for academy awards and won 4 of them alongside a string of other awards including a bafta for best film. The hobbit movies in order the hobbit is a movie trilogy that acts as a prequel to the popular lord of the rings trilogy. Here are the five biggest continuity errors you never noticed. Continuity is the consistency of what happens in the movie for a certain period. Why is the hobbit movie so different from the book. All mistakes 29 continuity mistakes 1 deliberate mistake 3 other mistakes 2 revealing mistakes order by popularity order chronologically add a plot summary add the ending titles starting with h continuity mistake. The lord of the rings series is known by many as one of the most impressive and iconic works in the history of film. Tolkeins four books made six movies, and many fans were split over it. The goal was accomplished on 25 march 3019, and aragorn was crowned king aragorn ii elessar on 1 may of that year. While the lord of the rings was adored by fans and critics alike, the hobbit was seen as a bit much. Ive explored the continuity errors, plot holes and technical slips to. Bakshi, whod been obsessed with the idea of doing an animated version of the story since the fifties begged ua for the chance to direct.

The website has a list of some of the years biggest mishaps. May be done intentionally, or incidentally, possibly because writers cannot do math. Im wondering how they flow together or not at all, i know peter jackson and company tried hard to make sure they connected to the lotr films. In addition to these two main goals, i also aimed to remove any and all other unneeded bloat from the film, ranging from cutting entire action sequences, to single lines of dialogue. For example, the marx brothers classic film duck soup, at the climax of the film, the camera shows a shot of groucho marx speaking a line, followed by a shot of something else happening, followed by another shot of groucho.

The battle of the five armies, from the perspective of a lord of the rings superfan who. Continuity between the hobbit and lord of the rings movies. Continuity between the hobbit and lord of the rings movies i was wondering if anyone has seen the battle of the five armies and the fellowship of the ring back to back yet. Unless fili has an exceptionally severe blood disorder, youd expect the director to keep track of continuity errors like this. The twins help, but elladan and elrohir can be evil.

The sword that is affectionately known as sting has a magic property, it glows blue when enemies are near. Theres no one way to correct these errors and many end up in a blooper reel. The first time i actually paid attention to the continuity errors was while watching sudden impact 1983. It also does not explain the million other absurd things in the movie countless. First off, i have not read the books, so if the answer to any of my questions is explaned in the books, just say that. Movie mistakes, we bring you fails, bloopers and goof that slip past editing and onto the big. Although the ring might preclude frodo looking much older, in the book he is 50 a good mature age for a hobbit when he leaves but in the movie frodo very much acts like a young hobbit often looking to sam for guidance when in fact sam is 12 years younger than frodo. In this movie, gandalf looks older than he does in his grey incarnation in lord of the rings. See more ideas about movie mistakes, movies and mistakes. Character error 1 continuity 20 incorrectly regarded as goofs 1. The fellowship of the ring was the first movie in the trilogy. Just when you thought it was safe to go back in the shire, warner bros. Most continuity errors are subtle and minor, such as changes in the level of drink in a characters glass or the length of a cigarette, and can be permitted with relative indifference even to the final cut.

Others can be more noticeable, such as sudden drastic changes in appearance of a character. May 31, 2017 all 6 peter jacksons middleearth movies ranked from worst to best posted on may 31, 2017 may 31, 2017 by allan khumalo peter jacksons adaptation of j. Film continuity is described as shots taken from different angles and composition at a single location must have the same position of characters, properties, objects, costumes and even dialogs. He always has to fix them when they show up halfdead from their wild and generally idiotic adventures. After reading the hobbit, it made sense that they had a previous relationship. However, in the filmtrilogy, balin is supposed to be the oldest member of the company, thorin allegedly being several years younger than dwalin. See more ideas about movie mistakes, mistakes and movies. Frozen two and how this movie teaches young girls and. Sometimes a work of fiction may deliberately employ continuity errors, usually for comedy. By 1969 the movie rights to the lord of the rings had found their way to united artists, where stanley kubrick and john boorman both had a crack at adapting it, with boorman turning in a 700 page script that no one at the studio could even understand. The hobbit jackson movies works archive of our own. When sam is in his bedroom, after he finds the cube sliver it falls and dramatically burns a hole through the floor into the kitchen.

I always thought that would leave people scratching their heads if they hadnt read the books. Dec 30, 2016 the lord of the rings movie mistakes movie mistakes, spoilers, bloopers, goof and fails. Shocking mistakes you missed in lord of the rings screenrant. There are plenty of examples of where continuity errors make the final cut. This is an article outlining the disappointments of the hobbit. The hobbit is a movie trilogy that acts as a prequel to the popular lord of the rings trilogy. Dec 23, 2012 the hobbit is my favourite book, so i was distressed to see the failure of the movie adaptation. Dec 19, 2014 this is an article outlining the disappointments of the hobbit. Without further ado, here are the 15 worst continuity mistakes in movie history. Because a film is not shot in the way we view it, it is very difficult to maintain its continuity. What inconsistencies, if any, appear in the hobbit, lord. Certain facts or events are presented in a series that contradict earlier episodes.

The plot hinges on the fact that morbius was supposedly never bitten before. Im wondering how they flow together or not at all, i know peter jackson and company tried hard to. When we first see alfrid with the master of laketown, he is talking about the rebellious people. There is a certain amount of creative license that enters into any film adaptation of a book. It explains certain aspects of both the book and movie that were previously left up to the imagination of. We know that because in lord of the rings frodo has it, and it does indeed glow blue when enemies are. Possible continuity error in the lord of the rings film. The entire premise of the movie revolves around him being just a hobbit. Director peter jackson used all his filmmaking ability and wetas cgi wizardry to take audiences into the bowels of middleearth for his lord of the rings trilogy. On the last hobbit movie, after the battle of the five armies, legolas tells thranduil that he wont be coming home.

But, the battle of the five armies was fought on t. Jul 08, 2018 continuity is the consistency of what happens in the movie for a certain period. The battle of the five armies, from the perspective of a lord of the rings superfan who knows peter jackson could have done it so. While the hobbit may only be one book, like peter jacksons lord of the rings films it was a trilogy on screen. Due to the ample time provided by covid19 quarantines, i finally have had time to address frequently reported issues with audio lag. Bilbo is said to live in bag end, underhill, hobbiton. Compare beyond the impossible, which is about characters breaking the storys internal logic by doing what is physically impossible. Some chapters are sequential, others are just snippets. Many critics have given their opinions why the film is a disappointment, but i believe we need to go back to the source material and witness how a new story was created to see what went wrong.

Everything that doesnt seem to match the character, the plot, or the environment is considered a mistake, unless. This series follows both the book and movie verses, and so can contain continuity errors. All 6 peter jacksons middleearth movies ranked from worst. There are a lot of inconsistencies between the hobbit and lotr. Three epic main films and three slightly less epic prequels concluded by the return of the king, which in its extended form clocks in at over four hours long related. A series of scenes from the many times that the elf lord fixes our two troublemakers. Dont read too much into any of the plot, just enjoy the usual fluff and funnies, with a bit of real angst in there to keep it interesting. Moviemaking can be trial and error, and sometimes, error wins out. The movie is set in 1985, but if you look behind ron woodroof matthew mcconaughey, you can see a lamborghini aventador, a car that wasnt made until 2011. However, the extra battle sequences are not only entertaining, but fix all of the continuity errors and seemingly random scenes that were present in the theatrical cut. Nov 20, 2015 however, the extra battle sequences are not only entertaining, but fix all of the continuity errors and seemingly random scenes that were present in the theatrical cut. Weve taken a look at ten of the most interesting continuity errors from across all three films. Even still, in the 2009 disney animated movie the princess and the frog, tiana experienced just that.

While the series doesnt live up to its lord of the rings brothers, it has just as many blunders. Dvd talk forum questions, continuity errors, and things. It takes place 60 years before the fellowship of the ring, and serves the purpose of filling in details that previously went unexplained. With such a prestigious history you may think the fellowship of the ring is. The extended cut has an additional 20 minutes added, most of which are battle scenes, but there are a few great dialogue scenes added. The hobbit is a single narrative and, while it is incredibly episodic, it doesnt merit an annual pause to take in the basic plot. Also, if something here will possibly be explained in the next movie, just say that rather than answering the question. All 6 peter jacksons middleearth movies ranked from. Questions, continuity errors, and things i just dont get. This is a wonderful introduction to these characters, but it has a small continuity problem. Virtually any movie, even a great one, can fall victim to continuity errors and factual inaccuracies.

Continuity mistakes in movies and why you dont see them. Repeat view the transcript the videomaker editors are dedicated to bringing you the information you need to produce and. Most cartoon characters wear the same outfit for their whole lives. For example, the term the shire is never used at all, anywhere, in the hobbit. Dvd talk forum questions, continuity errors, and things i. The hobbit is my favourite book, so i was distressed to see the failure of the movie adaptation. Thats one of the main advantages of animated movies you cant really fall prey to continuity errors. On top of teasing out every possible event from the novel itself, the films have had copious subplots from the return of the king appendices and. It is one of the biggest errors which amature or professional filmmakers often make. Sep 24, 2019 most cartoon characters wear the same outfit for their whole lives.

Some of the highestgrossing films in 2012 had errors in continuity. When bilbo brings the two bowls of stew for fili and kili theres a spoon in each of the bowls, but after bilbo sets down the bowls one of the. At the dinner scene at bilbo s house, just before bofur throws the egg at bomburs mouth, fili is seen sitting next to bombur. Here are 15 shocking mistakes you missed in lord of the rings. Bilbos height in comparison to gandalfs changes throughout the movie. The biggest errors in movie continuity you never noticed. Its especially noticeable because it happens straight away. Five big continuity errors the office thought they and their show perfect, but they cant get anything past me. The latter tells him to go to find the infamous son of arathorn, that goes by the name of strider. However, this takes place before the lord of the rings trilogy, so he should look younger, or the same. On his left shoulder is a big splat of yellow goo, probably from a thrown egg. And history teaches us that no matter how faithful or unfaithful a film adaptation is with respect to its original source, someone will complain about the movies unfaithfulness to the books. Jan 26, 20 10 biggest the lord of the rings movie mistakes so far lord of the rings movie mistakes duration. First, we see her wearing exclamation pointshaped gold earrings.